Friday, January 29, 2016

Immunity and Chlorine

I was sent a link to a Facebook post about a guy (we will call Jean-Claude) who is complaining about the quality of Windsor's drinking water. I will admit that this is an area I don't have that much knowledge in but I have taken one course on water treatment and health so I have the beginnings of an understanding in this.

Jean-Claude's concern was about the chlorine concentration and also asking “doesn't chlorine lower immune systems, cause cancer and other bad stuff?” He showed a picture of a pool water testing kit which he claimed contained tap water (I will assume he was honest in that claim). He suggested that the concentration was at pool level (1.0..although when I look at the photo it appears to be at 0.5) and also claimed that since people say that you shouldn't drink pool water, then that means the tap water is unsafe. He also made a claim that showering for 15 mins allows for you to absorb 1 gallon of water through the skin by absorption.

There is a lot to go through here but lets get to the short answer first. Is the city water safe to drink? Yes. According to Enwin, “Chlorine is added on a continuous basis to the water leaving the treatment process at a strictly controlled concentration of 1.5 mg/l...the concentration of chlorine in the water is monitored at 18 locations through the distribution system on a daily basis to ensure an adequate concentration is maintained to ensure a safe supply of water to the customers.”

In regards to “lowers immune systems, causes cancer and other bad stuff”: “Health Canada has classified chlorine as unlikely to be carcinogenic to humans. Studies in laboratory animals and humans indicate that chlorine exhibits low toxicity, regardless of the route of exposure (i.e., ingestion, inhalation, dermal). Studies in animals have not been able to identify a concentration of chlorine associated with adverse health effects, in part because of aversion to its taste and odour. No adverse health effects have been observed in humans from consuming water with high chlorine levels (up to 50 mg/L) over a short period of time.” Now some people may not like the taste or smell of chlorine but they can easily install a filter in their home to remove it.

Jean-Claude said you shouldn't drink pool water. This I agree with, but not for the same reasons Jean-Claude thinks. He thinks it's because of the chlorine content. I would say it's because a pool is an open system where it has continual exposure to pollutants. People are swimming in the pool just for starters. Would you want to drink water from a bath tub that had someone was bathing in? I would think it unlikely. A pool also has insects (and other animals including birds), dirt and debris all entering it. Water from your tap is not accessible to the same type of contamination with the exception of water pipe breakage. You may also be interested in this article I wrote (under a pseudonym) about the problems with enclosed pools and water parks: http://www.windsorsquare.ca/archives/67286/why-i-avoid-indoor-water-parks

So now to the final claim of water absorption through the skin. This is the real reason why I chose this question because I do love laughable claims and this one sure made me laugh that I did my best Mark Wahlberg impression from The Happening http://i.imgur.com/fx7N61c.gif smile emoticon
Seriously though, the skin can absorb some things although it generally is water-resistant but is not water-proof. It's the keratin and sebum (an oil), that helps keep it at bay. You can see its effectiveness when you start to prune when in water too long. So yes it can absorb some water, but it wouldn't be enough to stop you from dehydrating. A gallon of water is a lot of water considering we only need to consume 2.5 quarts, or just over half a gallon, per day depending on individual needs. By Jean-Claude's meter, we would never have to consume water. It is interesting to note that during my looking up info for all this, I found a Danish group did do a study, albeit a small and no control study, to test an old myth of getting drunk by absorption of alcohol through the skin. As you can probably guess, it was confirmed a myth.

Well I hope that answers your question.

Sources:
http://www.enwin.com/customerservice/residential/faqs.water.cfm#15
http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/ewh-semt/pubs/water-eau/chlorine-chlore/index-eng.php
http://www.bmj.com/content/341/bmj.c6812

"The Weather Channel founder says so." And.....?

Weather Forecaster: A person who predicts short term weather. Often may also be just a person who relays information through the media. May have some formal education on the subject.

Climatologist: A person who studies long term (years to thousands of years) weather and climate, Has formal education degrees on the subject.

So when a meme says a weatherman is a climate change denier, this is merely a lame appeal to authority. (http://www.snopes.com/politics/science/coleman.asp) Many would also use this idea to confirm their already biased views without any real research or study into the subject (by that I mean actual university/college courses. There is no excuse really when some beginning courses are now offered free!).

The degree of severity is always up for debate, and it's lively debated among climatologists (which is a good thing for zeroing in on what actually is happening). Sure there are some people who will go extreme environmentalism on you which will not give any effective solutions that wouldn't cause other harms in the process. So it's best to deal with the problem with a rational level head that is educated. Here's just one of those free courses that is starting tomorrow. https://www.edx.org/course/climate-change-science-ubcx-climate1x


What about that rat study?

A person asked "What about this study that showed rats getting cancer?"

What this person is referring to is the now infamous Seralini rat study, which much like the infamous Wakefield autism study, has been heralded as proof by the anti crowd. In scientific/reality arena though it's a constant annoying mosquito.

Here are a couple of problems with the study. First, it's been retracted: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0278691512005637
It had problems with the kind of rodent chosen (which is prone to tumors in the first place), the number of rodents in each group (which was very small). Its conclusions have been deemed inconclusive.

One curious thing too is that the data shows something that counters what the anti-gmoers were trying to show. The data was showing a correlation that if you drink pure water, you have a 50% higher mortality rate than if one drank water contaminated with herbicide. Yeah, figure that one out! wink emoticon

There was a question of ethics as well as Seralini let the tumors grow to an enormous size on the rodents, thus letting them exist in pain for an extended period of time. These animals should've been put to sleep long before they reached a point where tumors were the size of golfballs (which is huge when compared to the size of a body of a rat).

So if you see any website, meme, person using this study (which Seralini has now published in an open-access journal of little relevance or significance)to promote an anti-gmo stance it would be best to pass it off as nonsense. As I've always said, it's fine to hold a particular view, just make sure if you are trying to claim something that it's backed by good evidence and rational thought. Spouting problematic or false info doesn't help your cause.

More on Mosquitos

As the colder weather hits us, many Canadians head South to warmer climates for vacations. It's important to think about protection from Mosquitos. A new study that has come out gives further insight into what works and what doesn't (http://jinsectscience.oxfordjournals.org/content/15/1/140#fn-5 )
What they found was that the DEET repellents worked well (Repel 100, OFF Deep Woods VIII, Cutter Skinsations) for 4 hours of protection.

Cutter lemon eucalyptus was as good as Repel 100.

Cutter Natural, EcoSmart organic, Mosquito skin patch and Avon Skin So Soft Bug Guard repellents barely lasted a few minutes if at all.

Interestingly Avon Skin So Soft Bath Oil showed a medium range repellent effect for 2 hours.

Even more surprising was Victoria Secret Bombshell perfume showed a very significant effect for 2 hours.

Stay smart and stay protected.